I like your A/R argument. I go back and forth too. Which I'm ok with. I figure if Eddie and Mary have differing opinions on when they frakked, it's ok for me to not know for sure. I like the disquiet was the first time argument. It makes sense for what we saw on the show. The only thing that makes me doubt is the fact that they were living together for months (oh however long it was) before then. And I can't see her being in his quarters for that long (or however long it was) without something happening. But as I said I can't make up my mind definitely one way or the other.