Gah, I even go back & forth on the "did they get frisky" though. At least I have my "they didn't frak" to feel sure of. I mean, I can buy they at least had a chaste kiss, that's no problem. Because they did in season 2. But whether they full-on made out? I just can't say. The thing I always think of is that moment in "A Day in the Life" when Adama is talking to Carol Anne in his mind & she brings up how maybe Roslin likes bad boys and he's like "she's the president of the twelve colonies." Which to me seems like one of those situations where one part of your brain is saying, "maybe they like you!" and the other's going, "it's not appropriate!" You'd think if they went past a chaste kiss, he'd KNOW she liked him, wouldn't you?

edited to add: does it make me an angst-whore that I kind of love the heartbreakingness though? Ha. I mean, I do get the desire to want to see them together when she's got her hair and all too. That's why I love NC fic and all. But there's something just so achingly wonderful about them getting together in s4 that I can't resist too.